path: root/CONTRIBUTING.md

# Contributing

Feedback and contributions are very welcome!

Here's help on how to make contributions, divided into the following sections:

The quick-read part:
* general information,
* vulnerability reporting,
* documentation.

The long-read part:
* code changes,
* how to check proposed changes before submitting them,
* reuse of other libraries, frameworks etc.

## General information

For specific proposals, please provide them as
[pull requests](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libQMatrixClient/pulls)
or
[issues](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libqmatrxclient/issues)
For general discussion, feel free to use our Matrix room:
[#quaternion:matrix.org](https://matrix.to/#/#quaternion:matrix.org).

If you're new to the project (or FLOSS in general),
[issues tagged as easy](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libQMatrixClient/labels/easy)
are smaller tasks that may typically take 1-3 days.
You are welcome aboard!

### Pull requests and different branches recommended

Pull requests are preferred, since they are specific.
See the GitHub Help [articles about pull requests](https://help.github.com/articles/using-pull-requests/)
to learn how to deal with them.

We recommend creating different branches for different (logical)
changes, and creating a pull request when you're done into the master branch.
See the GitHub documentation on
[creating branches](https://help.github.com/articles/creating-and-deleting-branches-within-your-repository/)
and
[using pull requests](https://help.github.com/articles/using-pull-requests/).

### How we handle proposals

We use GitHub to track all changes via its
[issue tracker](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libQMatrixClient/issues) and
[pull requests](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libQMatrixClient/pulls).
Specific changes are proposed using those mechanisms.
Issues are assigned to an individual who works on it and then marks it complete.
If there are questions or objections, the conversation area of that
issue or pull request is used to resolve it.

<!--
### Developer Certificate of Origin (DCO) - not enforced yet

All contributions (including pull requests) must agree to
the [Developer Certificate of Origin (DCO) version 1.1](doc/dco.txt).
This is exactly the same one created and used by the Linux kernel developers
and posted on <http://developercertificate.org/>.
This is a developer's certification that he or she has the right to
submit the patch for inclusion into the project.

Simply submitting a contribution implies this agreement, however,
please include a "Signed-off-by" tag in every patch
(this tag is a conventional way to confirm that you agree to the DCO).
You can do this with <tt>git commit --signoff</tt> (the <tt>-s</tt> flag
is a synonym for <tt>--signoff</tt>).

Another way to do this is to write the following at the end of the commit
message, on a line by itself separated by a blank line from the body of
the commit:

    Signed-off-by: YOUR NAME <YOUR.EMAIL@EXAMPLE.COM>

You can signoff by default in this project by creating a file
(say "git-template") that contains
some blank lines and the signed-off-by text above;
then configure git to use that as a commit template.  For example:

    git config commit.template ~/cii-best-practices-badge/git-template

It's not practical to fix old contributions in git, so if one is forgotten,
do not try to fix them.  We presume that if someone sometimes used a DCO,
a commit without a DCO is an accident and the DCO still applies.
-->
### License

Unless a contributor explicitly specifies otherwise, we assume contributors
to agree that all contributed code is released either under *LGPL v2.1 or later*.
This is more than just [LGPL v2.1 libQMatrixClient now uses](./COPYING)
because the project plans to switch to LGPL v3 for library code in the near future.
<!-- The below is invalid yet!
All new contributed material that is not executable, including all text when not executed, is also released under the
[Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) or later.
-->

Any components proposed for reuse should have a license that permits releasing
a derivative work under *LGPL v2.1 or later* or LGPL v3. Moreover, the license of
a proposed component should be approved by OSI, no exceptions.

## Vulnerability reporting (security issues)

If you find a significant vulnerability, or evidence of one,
use either of the following contacts:
* send an email to Kitsune Ral [Kitsune-Ral@users.sf.net](mailto:Kitsune-Ral@users.sf.net)
* reach out in Matrix to #kitsune:matrix.org (if you can, switch encryption **on**)

In any of these two options, _indicate that you have such information_
(do not share the information yet), and we'll tell you the next steps.

By default, we will give credit to anyone who reports a vulnerability in
a responsible way so that we can fix it before public disclosure. If you want
to remain anonymous or pseudonymous instead, please let us know; we will
gladly respect your wishes. If you provide a fix as a PR, you have no way
to remain anonymous (and you also disclose the vulnerability thereby) so this
is not the right way, unless the vulnerability is already made public.

## Documentation changes

Most of the documentation is in Markdown format. All Markdown files use the .md
filename extension. Any help on fixing/extending these is more than welcome.

Where reasonable, limit yourself to Markdown that will be accepted by different
markdown processors (e.g., what is specified by CommonMark or the original
Markdown). In practice, as long as libQMatrixClient is hosted at GitHub,
[GFM (GitHub-flavoured Markdown)](https://help.github.com/articles/github-flavored-markdown/)
is used to show those files in a browser, so it's fine to use its extensions.
In particular, you can mark code snippets with the programming language used;
blank lines separate paragraphs, newlines inside a paragraph do *not* force a line break.

Beware - this is *not* the same markdown algorithm used by GitHub when it
renders issue or pull comments; in those cases
[newlines in paragraph-like content are considered as real line breaks](https://help.github.com/articles/writing-on-github/);
unfortunately this other algorithm is *also* called GitHub-flavoured markdown.
(Yes, it'd be better if there were different names for different things.)

In your markdown, please don't use tab characters and avoid "bare" URLs.
In a hyperlink, the link text and URL should be on the same line.
While historically we didn't care about the line length in markdown texts
(and more often than not put the whole paragraph into one line), this is subject
to change anytime soon, with 80-character limit _recommendation_
(which is softer than the limit for C/C++ code) imposed on everything
_except hyperlinks_ (because wrapping hyperlinks breaks the rendering).

Do not use trailing two spaces for line breaks, since these cannot be seen
and may be silently removed by some tools. If, for whatever reason, a blank line
is not an option, use <tt>&lt;br&nbsp;/&gt;</tt> (an HTML break).

## End of TL;DR

If you don't plan/have substantial contributions, you can end reading here. Further sections are for those who's going to actively hack on the library code.

## Code changes

The code should strive to be DRY (don't repeat yourself), clear, and obviously correct. Some technical debt is inevitable, just don't bankrupt us with it. Refactoring is welcome.

### Generated C++ code for CS API
The code in lib/csapi, lib/identity and lib/application-service, although
it resides in Git, is actually generated from (a soft fork of) the official
Matrix Swagger/OpenAPI definition files. If you're unhappy with something in
these directories and want to improve the code, you have to understand the way
these files are produced and setup some additional tooling. The shortest
possible procedure resembling the below text can be found in .travis.yml
(our Travis CI configuration actually regenerates those files upon every build).
The generating sequence only works with CMake atm;
patches to enable it with qmake are (you guessed it) very welcome.

#### Why generate the code at all?
Because before both original authors of libQMatrixClient had to do monkey business of writing boilerplate code, with the same patterns, types etc., literally, for every single API endpoint, and one of the authors got fed up with it at some point in time. By then about 15 job classes were written; the entire API counts about 100 endpoints. Besides, the existing jobs had to be updated according to changes in CS API that have been, and will keep, coming. Other considerations can be found in [this talk about API description languages that briefly touches on GTAD](https://youtu.be/W5TmRozH-rg).

#### Prerequisites for CS API code generation
1. Get the source code of GTAD and its dependencies, e.g. using the command: `git clone --recursive https://github.com/KitsuneRal/gtad.git`
2. Build GTAD: in the source code directory, do `cmake . && cmake --build .` (you might need to pass `-DCMAKE_PREFIX_PATH=<path to Qt>`, similar to libQMatrixClient itself).
3. Get the Matrix CS API definitions that are included in the matrix-doc repo: `git clone https://github.com/QMatrixClient/matrix-doc.git` (QMatrixClient/matrix-doc is a fork that's known to produce working code; you may want to use your own fork if you wish to alter something in the API).

#### Generating CS API contents
1. Pass additional configuration to CMake when configuring libQMatrixClient:
   `-DMATRIX_DOC_PATH=<path you your matrix-doc repo> -DGTAD_PATH=<path to gtad binary (not the repo!)>`.
   If everything's right, these two CMake variables will be mentioned in
   CMake output and will trigger configuration of an additional build target,
   see the next step.
2. Generate the code: `cmake --build <your build dir> --target update-api`;
   if you use CMake with GNU Make, you can just do `make update-api` instead.
   Building this target will create (overwriting without warning) `.h` and `.cpp`
   files in `lib/csapi`, `lib/identity`, `lib/application-service` for all
   YAML files it can find in `matrix-doc/api/client-server` and other files
   in `matrix-doc/api` these depend on.
3. Once you've done that, you can build the library as usual; rerunning CMake
   is recommended if the list of generated files has changed.

#### Changing generated code
See the more detailed description of what GTAD is and how it works in the documentation on GTAD in its source repo. Only parts specific for libQMatrixClient are described here.

GTAD uses the following three kinds of sources:
1. OpenAPI files. Each file is treated as a separate source (because this is how GTAD works now).
2. A configuration file, in our case it's lib/csapi/gtad.yaml - this one is common for the whole API.
3. Source code template files: lib/csapi/{{base}}.*.mustache - also common.

The mustache files have a templated (not in C++ sense) definition of a network job, deriving from BaseJob; each job class is prepended, if necessary, with data structure definitions used by this job. The look of those files is hideous for a newcomer; the fact that there's no highlighter for the combination of Mustache (originally a web templating language) and C++ doesn't help things, either. To slightly simplify things some more or less generic constructs are defined in gtad.yaml (see its "mustache:" section). Adventurous souls that would like to figure what's going on in these files should speak up in the libQMatrixClient room - I (Kitsune) will be very glad to help you out.

The types map in `gtad.yaml` is the central switchboard when it comes to matching OpenAPI types with C++ (and Qt) ones. It uses the following type attributes aside from pretty obvious "imports:":
* `avoidCopy` - this attribute defines whether a const ref should be used instead of a value. For basic types like int this is obviously unnecessary; but compound types like `QVector` should rather be taken by reference when possible.
* `moveOnly` - some types are not copyable at all and must be moved instead (an obvious example is anything "tainted" with a member of type `std::unique_ptr<>`). The template will use `T&&` instead of `T` or `const T&` to pass such types around.
* `useOmittable` - wrap types that have no value with "null" semantics (i.e. number types and custom-defined data structures) into a special `Omittable<>` template defined in `converters.h` - a substitute for `std::optional` from C++17 (we're still at C++14 yet).
* `omittedValue` - an alternative for `useOmittable`, just provide a value used for an omitted parameter. This is used for bool parameters which normally are considered false if omitted (or they have an explicit default value, passed in the "official" GTAD's `defaultValue` variable).
* `initializer` - this is a _partial_ (see GTAD and Mustache documentation for explanations but basically it's a variable that is a Mustache template itself) that specifies how exactly a default value should be passed to the parameter. E.g., the default value for a `QString` parameter is enclosed into `QStringLiteral`.

Instead of relying on the event structure definition in the OpenAPI files, `gtad.yaml` uses pointers to libQMatrixClient's event structures: `EventPtr`, `RoomEventPtr` and `StateEventPtr`. Respectively, arrays of events, when encountered in OpenAPI definitions, are converted to `Events`, `RoomEvents` and `StateEvents` containers. When there's no way to figure the type from the definition, an opaque `QJsonObject` is used, leaving the conversion to the library and/or client code.

### Library API and doc-comments

Whenever you add a new call to the library API that you expect to be used from client code, you must supply a proper doc-comment along with the call. Doxygen (with backslashes) style is preferred. You can find that some parts of the code still use JavaDoc (with @'s) style; feel free to replace it with Doxygen backslashes if that bothers you. Some parts are not even documented; adding doc-comments to them is highly encouraged.

Calls, data structures and other symbols not intended for use by clients
should _not_ be exposed in (public) .h files, unless they are necessary
to declare other public symbols. In particular, this involves private members
(functions, typedefs, or variables) in public classes; use pimpl idiom to hide
implementation details as much as possible. `_impl` namespace is reserved for
definitions that should not be used by clients and are not covered by
API guarantees.

Note: As of now, all header files of libQMatrixClient are considered public; this may change eventually.

### Qt-flavoured C++

This is our primary language. A particular code style is not enforced _yet_ but
[the PR imposing the common code style](https://github.com/QMatrixClient/libqmatrixclient/pull/295)
is planned to arrive in version 0.6.
* 4-space indents, no tabs, no trailing spaces, no last empty lines. If you
  spot the code abusing these - we'll thank you for fixing it.
* Prefer keeping lines within 80 characters.
* Braces after if's, while's, do's, function signatures etc. take
  a separate line. Keeping the opening brace on the same line is still ok.
* A historical deviation from the usual Qt code format conventions is an extra
  indent inside _classes_ (access specifiers go at +4 spaces to the base,
  members at +8 spaces) but not _structs_ (members at +4 spaces). This may
  change in the future for something more conventional.
* Please don't make "hypocritical structs" with protected or private members.
  In general, `struct` is used to denote a plain-old-data structure, rather
  than data+behaviour. If you need access control or are adding yet another
  non-trivial (construction, assignment) member function to a `struct`,
  just make it a `class` instead.
* For newly created classes, keep to
  [the rule of 3/5/0](http://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/language/rule_of_three) -
  make sure to read about the rule of zero if you haven't before, it's not
  what you might think it is.
* Qt containers are generally preferred to STL containers; however, there are
  notable exceptions, and libQMatrixClient already uses them:
  * `std::array` and `std::deque` have no direct counterparts in Qt.
  * Because of COW semantics, Qt containers cannot hold uncopyable classes.
    Classes without a default constructor are a problem too. Examples of that
    are `SyncRoomData` and `EventsArray<>`. Use STL containers for those but
    see the next point and also consider if you can supply a reasonable
    copy/default constructor.
  * STL containers can be freely used in code internal to a translation unit
    (i.e., in a certain .cpp file) _as long as that is not exposed in the API_.
    It's ok to use, e.g., `std::vector` instead of `QVector` to tighten up
    code where you don't need COW, or when dealing with uncopyable
    data structures (see the previous point). However, exposing STL containers
    in the API is not encouraged (except where absolutely necessary, e.g. we use
    `std::deque` for a timeline). Exposing STL containers or iterators in API
    intended for usage by QML code (e.g. in `Q_PROPERTY`) is unlikely to work
    and therefore unlikely to be accepted into `master`.
* Use `QVector` instead of `QList` where possible - see the
  [great article by Marc Mutz on Qt containers](https://marcmutz.wordpress.com/effective-qt/containers/)
  for details.

### Automated tests

There's no testing framework as of now; either Catch or Qt Test or both will
be used eventually.

As a stopgap measure, qmc-example is used for automated functional testing.
Therefore, any significant addition to the library API should be accompanied
by a respective test in qmc-example. To add a test you should:
- Add a new private slot to the `QMCTest` class.
- Add to the beginning of the slot the line `running.push_back("Test name");`.
- Add test logic to the slot, using `QMC_CHECK` macro to assert the test outcome. ALL (even failing) branches should conclude with a QMC_CHECK invocation, unless you intend to have a "DID NOT FINISH" message in the logs under certain conditions.
- Call the slot from `QMCTest::startTests()`.

`QMCTest` sets up some basic test fixture to help you with testing; notably by the moment `startTests()` is invoked you can rely on having a working connection in `c` member variable and a test room in `targetRoom` member variable. PRs to introduce a proper testing framework are very welcome (make sure to migrate tests from qmc-example though); shifting qmc-example to use Qt Test seems to be a particularly low-hanging fruit.

### Security, privacy, and performance

Pay attention to security, and work *with* (not against) the usual security hardening mechanisms (however few in C++).

`char *` and similar unchecked C-style read/write arrays are forbidden - use Qt containers or at the very least `std::array<>` instead. Where you see fit (usually with data structures), try to use smart pointers, especially `std::unique_ptr<>` or `QScopedPointer` instead of bare pointers. When dealing with `QObject`s, use the parent-child ownership semantics exercised by Qt (this is preferred to using smart pointers). Shared pointers are not used in the code so far; but if you find a particular use case where the strict semantic of unique pointers doesn't help and a shared pointer is necessary, feel free to step up with the working code and it will be considered for inclusion.

Exercise the [principle of least privilege](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_least_privilege) where reasonable and appropriate. Prefer less-coupled cohesive code.

Protect private information, in particular passwords and email addresses. Absolutely _don't_ spill around this information in logs - use `access_token` and similar opaque ids instead, and only display those in UI where needed. Do not forget about local access to data (in particular, be very careful when storing something in temporary files, let alone permanent configuration or state). Avoid mechanisms that could be used for tracking where possible (we do need to verify people are logged in but that's pretty much it), and ensure that third parties can't use interactions for tracking. Matrix protocols evolve towards decoupling the personally identifiable information from user activity entirely - follow this trend.

We want the software to have decent performance for typical users. At the same time we keep libQMatrixClient single-threaded as much as possible, to keep the code simple. That means being cautious about operation complexity (read about big-O notation if you need a kickstart on the topic). This especially refers to operations on the whole timeline and the list of users - each of these can have tens of thousands of elements so even operations with linear complexity, if heavy enough, can produce noticeable GUI freezing. When you don't see a way to reduce algorithmic complexity, embed occasional `processEvents()` invocations in heavy loops (see `Connection::saveState()` to get the idea).

Having said that, there's always a trade-off between various attributes; in particular, readability and maintainability of the code is more important than squeezing every bit out of that clumsy algorithm. Beware of premature optimization and have profiling data around before going into some hardcore optimization.

Speaking of profiling logs (see README.md on how to turn them on) - in order
to reduce small timespan logging spam, there's a default limit of at least
200 microseconds to log most operations with the PROFILER
(aka libqmatrixclient.profile.debug) logging category. You can override this
limit by passing the new value (in microseconds) in PROFILER_LOG_USECS to
the compiler. In the future, this parameter will be made changeable at runtime
_if_ needed.

## How to check proposed changes before submitting them

Checking the code on at least one configuration is essential; if you only have
a hasty fix that doesn't even compile, better make an issue and put a link to
your commit into it (with an explanation what it is about and why).

### Standard checks

The following warnings configuration is applied with GCC and Clang when using CMake:
`-W -Wall -Wextra -pedantic -Werror=return-type -Wno-unused-parameter -Wno-gnu-zero-variadic-macro-arguments`
(the last one is to mute a warning triggered by Qt code for debug logging).
We don't turn most of the warnings to errors but please treat them as such.
In Qt Creator, the following line can be used with the Clang code model
(before Qt Creator 4.7 you should explicitly enable the Clang code model plugin):
`-Weverything -Werror=return-type -Wno-c++98-compat -Wno-c++98-compat-pedantic -Wno-unused-macros -Wno-newline-eof -Wno-exit-time-destructors -Wno-global-constructors -Wno-gnu-zero-variadic-macro-arguments -Wno-documentation -Wno-missing-prototypes -Wno-shadow-field-in-constructor -Wno-padded -Wno-weak-vtables -Wno-unknown-attributes -Wno-comma`.

### Continuous Integration

We use Travis CI to check buildability and smoke-testing on Linux (GCC, Clang) and MacOS (Clang), and AppVeyor CI to build on Windows (MSVC). Every PR will go through these, and you'll see the traffic lights from them on the PR page. If your PR fails on any platform double-check that it's not your code causing it - and fix it if it is.

### Other tools

Recent versions of Qt Creator and CLion can automatically run your code through
clang-tidy. The following list of clang-tidy checks slows Qt Creator analysis
quite considerably but gives a good insight without too many false positives:
`-*,bugprone-argument-comment,bugprone-assert-side-effect,bugprone-bool-pointer-implicit-conversion,bugprone-copy-constructor-init,bugprone-dangling-handle,bugprone-fold-init-type,bugprone-forward-declaration-namespace,bugprone-inaccurate-erase,bugprone-integer-division,bugprone-move-forwarding-reference,bugprone-string-constructor,bugprone-undefined-memory-manipulation,bugprone-use-after-move,bugprone-virtual-near-miss,cert-dcl03-c,cert-dcl21-cpp,cert-dcl50-cpp,cert-dcl54-cpp,cert-dcl58-cpp,cert-env33-c,cert-err09-cpp,cert-err34-c,cert-err52-cpp,cert-err60-cpp,cert-err61-cpp,cert-fio38-c,cert-flp30-c,cert-msc30-c,cert-msc50-cpp,cert-oop11-cpp,cppcoreguidelines-c-copy-assignment-signature,cppcoreguidelines-pro-type-cstyle-cast,cppcoreguidelines-slicing,hicpp-deprecated-headers,hicpp-invalid-access-moved,hicpp-member-init,hicpp-move-const-arg,hicpp-named-parameter,hicpp-new-delete-operators,hicpp-static-assert,hicpp-undelegated-constructor,hicpp-use-*,misc-misplaced-const,misc-new-delete-overloads,misc-non-copyable-objects,misc-redundant-expression,misc-static-assert,misc-throw-by-value-catch-by-reference,misc-unconventional-assign-operator,misc-uniqueptr-reset-release,misc-unused-*,modernize-loop-convert,modernize-pass-by-value,modernize-return-braced-init-list,modernize-shrink-to-fit,modernize-unary-static-assert,modernize-use-*,performance-faster-string-find,performance-for-range-copy,performance-implicit-conversion-in-loop,performance-inefficient-*,performance-move-*,performance-type-promotion-in-math-fn,performance-unnecessary-*,readability-delete-null-pointer,readability-else-after-return,readability-inconsistent-declaration-parameter-name,readability-misleading-indentation,readability-redundant-*,readability-simplify-boolean-expr,readability-static-definition-in-anonymous-namespace,readability-uniqueptr-delete-release`.

Qt Creator, in addition, knows about clazy, an even deeper Qt-aware static
analysis tool. Even level 1 clazy eats away CPU but produces some very relevant
and unobvious notices, such as possible unintended copying of a Qt container,
or unguarded null pointers. You can use this time to time (see Analyze menu in
Qt Creator) instead of hogging your machine with deep analysis as you type.

## Git commit messages

When writing git commit messages, try to follow the guidelines in
[How to Write a Git Commit Message](https://chris.beams.io/posts/git-commit/):

1.  Separate subject from body with a blank line
2.  Be reasonable on the subject line length, because this is what we see in commit logs. Try to fit in 50 characters whenever possible.
3.  Capitalize the subject line
4.  Do not end the subject line with a period
5.  Use the imperative mood in the subject line (*command* form)
  (we don't always practice this ourselves but let's try).
6.  Use the body to explain what and why vs. how
    (git tracks how it was changed in detail, don't repeat that). Sometimes a quick overview of "how" is acceptable if a commit is huge - but maybe split a commit into smaller ones, to begin with?

## Reuse (libraries, frameworks, etc.)

C++ is unfortunately not very coherent about SDK/package management, and we try to keep building the library as easy as possible. Because of that we are very conservative about adding dependencies to libQMatrixClient. That relates to additional Qt components and even more to other libraries. Fortunately, even the Qt components now in use (Qt Core and Network) are very feature-rich and provide plenty of ready-made stuff.

Regardless of the above paragraph (and as mentioned earlier in the text), we're now looking at possible options for futures and automated testing, so PRs onboarding those will be considered with much gratitude.

Some cases need additional explanation:
* Before rolling out your own super-optimised container or algorithm written
  from scratch, take a good long look through documentation on Qt and
  C++ standard library. Please try to reuse the existing facilities
  as much as possible.
* You should have a good reason (or better several ones) to add a component
  from KDE Frameworks. We don't rule this out and there's no prejudice against
  KDE; it just so happened that KDE Frameworks is one of most obvious
  reuse candidates but so far none of these components survived
  as libQMatrixClient deps. So we are cautious. Extra notice to KDE folks:
  I'll be happy if an addon library on top of libQMatrixClient is made using
  KDE facilities, and I'm willing to take part in its evolution; but please
  also respect LXDE people who normally don't have KDE frameworks installed.
* Never forget that libQMatrixClient is aimed to be a non-visual library;
  QtGui in dependencies is only driven by (entirely offscreen) dealing with
  QImages. While there's a bunch of visual code (in C++ and QML) shared
  between libQMatrixClient-enabled _applications_, this is likely to end up
  in a separate (libQMatrixClient-enabled) library, rather than
  libQMatrixClient itself.

## Attribution

This text is based on CONTRIBUTING.md from CII Best Practices Badge project, which is a collective work of its contributors (many thanks!). The text itself is licensed under CC-BY-4.0.